I'd like to be able to hunt with Bow, Rifle and MZ. I'd like to be able to take a nice buck with any of them. I won't shoot a little buck (I've eaten my rifle tag for the past two years holding out for a nice buck). If the tag was a "Season Choice" and I didn't see a nice one with my bow, then I'd try again with my rifle. Still no luck? Well, maybe I'll get him with my MZ.
The way it is now, a guy who wants to hunt with all three methods has to pick which one he DOESN'T want to shoot a buck with and go hunting with his "season choice" doe tag. I'd like to know that I have the ability to take a nice buck if I see one. Once I have one for the season I'll be happy to not shoot another buck. It would increase your chances at getting a nice buck and maybe some guys who would've shot a small buck might let him pass so they could wait for a bigger one?
They could offer Doe tags too so you could still take a doe with whatever method you wanted. I'd buy doe tags too so I could make sure I had some meat.
(I liked the carry-over tag idea too.)